The word “morality” in this conversation seems to convey three distinct but overlapping concepts, mores, morality and ethics. ( I get that the difference between morality and ethics is contentious, but for theis purpose I refer to behavior in society, rules of society, and individual choice of behavior.) Mores, especially in the technological age, change rapidly. Think about the widespread adoption of the smart phone around 2010. This greatly changed behavior in society and introduced many new moral and ethical quandaries. Changing mores effect morality. Morality changes too, more slowly, but inexorably. In contrast from the time Moses came down form the mountain, to when Jesus bore the cross to today, do unto others as you would have done to you defines ethical behavior. How that works in day to day life is the ob of religious and legal systems of morals.
For example, as a teenager in Louisiana I had to wear a blazer, tie, pressed shirt and dress pants and hard bottomed, leather shoes to church. Wearing your Sunday best was considered good moral behavior a show of respect for God and church. This moral belief holds far less sway toady. In fact a big reason for the popularity of mega churches is their come as you are, as you were, as a friend attitude. The moral codes changed. Now if you grow up with a certain moral code representing “good” then changes in that moral code might read “bad” as decline. The underlying ethical behavior may be the same or have improved. Think of the Victorians with their elaborate systems of morality underwriting by child labor in the home country and savage oppression of foreigners. So social traditionalists and egalitarians are both somewhat correct. Morality in the country has changed away from the moral codes they believed fostered ethical behavior. Statistical explanations of actual ethical behavior may differ from beliefs.
But moral change is not relative. Another example involves Congress. Newt Gingrich and Frank Luntz developed a well thought out political vocabulary, a sort of catechism, and instructed Republicans running for Congress to use this vocabulary for the express purpose of demonizing Democrats. This project served the neoliberal ideological purpose of permanently lower taxes. Grover Norquist acted as enforcer of only ever lowering and never raising taxes as a marker of “real” Republicans. Deviation resulted in being outcast as a RINO. This normalization of the demonization of an entire party marked a radical change in the moral codes of Congress, a place where, a few canings aside, had for two hundred years been ruled by the concept of mutual respect, decorum and free debate. This change does represent a decline in the mores, customs and morals of the institution. By neoliberal i mean the use of price as the primary unit of value in economics instead of human labor as the primary value in classical economics. Just as the spokespeople for neoliberalism, Thatcher and Reagan, live downstream from Jevons, Menger and Walras, McConnellism in the Senate and Trumpism in the White House flow downstream from Gingrich’s rejection of the equal rights and respect of his political opponents.
I agree that in many ways acceptance and respect for other people has greatly improved in recent decades with some glaring exceptions. Getting groups of people to agree on the right path to good behavior remains hard as it always has. The U.S. constitutional system is one of the most successful of those attempts, and despite a recent shift in political fortunes, the decline of that system has yet to be reversed.
Great post and I basically agree with all of it. There is, however, some evidence of moral decline specifically in the domain of prejudice specifically since 2020. It's an uptick in the context of much longer term declines, and the success of morality-prioritizing politicians in 2026 elections is good reason to think the American public is not just descending down a one-way path to ever-bigger bigotry
You are one of the most unique writers I have come across. This was very good. White pill but more importantly, very thorough and analytical. Please keep up the good work!
I haven't thought that America was in a moral decline as much as it is paralyzed by divisiveness. Both parties have ventured into extreme territory and the populace is herded into either camp. I see this all the time---friends on both sides toeing the party line and thinking the other side is the corrupt evil. That's no way to get anything done in this country---and look what we've accomplished with each party trying out spend each other---$40.5 trillion in debt. We're not morally bankrupt, just bankrupt.
This feels a bit too “both sides”. The amount of money this current administration has spent and the debt they've run up is vastly worse than other admins
Good read. Admittedly, I get caught up in strict political vs moral definitions. If tolerance for 70,000 people disappearing into ICE camps, deporting unaccompanied children and their other brutalities is in the political realm, not moral, then so is abortion.
Trump was largely a reaction against the ways America has been morally improving. During Obama, even his most unambiguously racist attackers still felt obligated to say “But I'm not a racist." Trump let them feel liberated to say “Racism is perfectly normal and I'm sick and tired of being told I should feel ashamed of it."
If Trump was a reaction to Obama, you'd expect Trump or a Trump-like figure to be nominated by the GOP in 2012. But the 2012 nominee, Romney, marched with BLM.
I actually looked into this, and during the 2012 campaign, Rick Santorum had a scandal where he may, or may not, have said he did not want to "make black people's lives better by giving them somebody else's money."
The Obama Backlash Hypothesis predicts that this "gaffe" should've caused Santorum to surge to the nomination. Instead, Mr. Capitalism got the nod.
Why did GOP views on racism shift so much between 2012 and 2016? During that period, a major shift started progressive culture where the term "racism" was applied in more and more contexts, to more and more statements and behaviors.
This is the period where MLK's iconic "judge not by color of skin but by content of character" quote went from north star to terribly problematic. The new progressive skeleton key was King's quote about his grave disappointment with the white moderate. That quote was never interpreted in its 1960s context, and created an environment where people had to continuously one-up each other in their social justice radicalism, to avoid being part of King's supposed "white moderate".
Taboos against "racism" went from a social contract (anyone could, in principle, be racist to anyone else, and the standards are identical, at least in theory) to a rhetorical weapon (black people are definitionally incapable of being racist to white people because "racism = power + prejudice").
This cultural shift created backlash which destroyed race relations. Scroll through X on any Thursday and you can see the old "judge not by color of skin but by content of character" social contract is looking pretty dead. A great tragedy.
The word “morality” in this conversation seems to convey three distinct but overlapping concepts, mores, morality and ethics. ( I get that the difference between morality and ethics is contentious, but for theis purpose I refer to behavior in society, rules of society, and individual choice of behavior.) Mores, especially in the technological age, change rapidly. Think about the widespread adoption of the smart phone around 2010. This greatly changed behavior in society and introduced many new moral and ethical quandaries. Changing mores effect morality. Morality changes too, more slowly, but inexorably. In contrast from the time Moses came down form the mountain, to when Jesus bore the cross to today, do unto others as you would have done to you defines ethical behavior. How that works in day to day life is the ob of religious and legal systems of morals.
For example, as a teenager in Louisiana I had to wear a blazer, tie, pressed shirt and dress pants and hard bottomed, leather shoes to church. Wearing your Sunday best was considered good moral behavior a show of respect for God and church. This moral belief holds far less sway toady. In fact a big reason for the popularity of mega churches is their come as you are, as you were, as a friend attitude. The moral codes changed. Now if you grow up with a certain moral code representing “good” then changes in that moral code might read “bad” as decline. The underlying ethical behavior may be the same or have improved. Think of the Victorians with their elaborate systems of morality underwriting by child labor in the home country and savage oppression of foreigners. So social traditionalists and egalitarians are both somewhat correct. Morality in the country has changed away from the moral codes they believed fostered ethical behavior. Statistical explanations of actual ethical behavior may differ from beliefs.
But moral change is not relative. Another example involves Congress. Newt Gingrich and Frank Luntz developed a well thought out political vocabulary, a sort of catechism, and instructed Republicans running for Congress to use this vocabulary for the express purpose of demonizing Democrats. This project served the neoliberal ideological purpose of permanently lower taxes. Grover Norquist acted as enforcer of only ever lowering and never raising taxes as a marker of “real” Republicans. Deviation resulted in being outcast as a RINO. This normalization of the demonization of an entire party marked a radical change in the moral codes of Congress, a place where, a few canings aside, had for two hundred years been ruled by the concept of mutual respect, decorum and free debate. This change does represent a decline in the mores, customs and morals of the institution. By neoliberal i mean the use of price as the primary unit of value in economics instead of human labor as the primary value in classical economics. Just as the spokespeople for neoliberalism, Thatcher and Reagan, live downstream from Jevons, Menger and Walras, McConnellism in the Senate and Trumpism in the White House flow downstream from Gingrich’s rejection of the equal rights and respect of his political opponents.
I agree that in many ways acceptance and respect for other people has greatly improved in recent decades with some glaring exceptions. Getting groups of people to agree on the right path to good behavior remains hard as it always has. The U.S. constitutional system is one of the most successful of those attempts, and despite a recent shift in political fortunes, the decline of that system has yet to be reversed.
Great post and I basically agree with all of it. There is, however, some evidence of moral decline specifically in the domain of prejudice specifically since 2020. It's an uptick in the context of much longer term declines, and the success of morality-prioritizing politicians in 2026 elections is good reason to think the American public is not just descending down a one-way path to ever-bigger bigotry
https://www.pnas.org/doi/pdf/10.1073/pnas.2619420123?download=true
You are one of the most unique writers I have come across. This was very good. White pill but more importantly, very thorough and analytical. Please keep up the good work!
I haven't thought that America was in a moral decline as much as it is paralyzed by divisiveness. Both parties have ventured into extreme territory and the populace is herded into either camp. I see this all the time---friends on both sides toeing the party line and thinking the other side is the corrupt evil. That's no way to get anything done in this country---and look what we've accomplished with each party trying out spend each other---$40.5 trillion in debt. We're not morally bankrupt, just bankrupt.
This feels a bit too “both sides”. The amount of money this current administration has spent and the debt they've run up is vastly worse than other admins
Neither side has done anything to improve the fiscal situation. GWB 6 trillion, Obama 9 trillion, Trump 1--5 trillion, Biden 8 trillion, Trump 2---the rest.
Good read. Admittedly, I get caught up in strict political vs moral definitions. If tolerance for 70,000 people disappearing into ICE camps, deporting unaccompanied children and their other brutalities is in the political realm, not moral, then so is abortion.
Trump was largely a reaction against the ways America has been morally improving. During Obama, even his most unambiguously racist attackers still felt obligated to say “But I'm not a racist." Trump let them feel liberated to say “Racism is perfectly normal and I'm sick and tired of being told I should feel ashamed of it."
If Trump was a reaction to Obama, you'd expect Trump or a Trump-like figure to be nominated by the GOP in 2012. But the 2012 nominee, Romney, marched with BLM.
I actually looked into this, and during the 2012 campaign, Rick Santorum had a scandal where he may, or may not, have said he did not want to "make black people's lives better by giving them somebody else's money."
https://www.npr.org/sections/itsallpolitics/2012/01/03/144613385/santorum-explains-his-comments-about-black-people-and-entitlements
The Obama Backlash Hypothesis predicts that this "gaffe" should've caused Santorum to surge to the nomination. Instead, Mr. Capitalism got the nod.
Why did GOP views on racism shift so much between 2012 and 2016? During that period, a major shift started progressive culture where the term "racism" was applied in more and more contexts, to more and more statements and behaviors.
This is the period where MLK's iconic "judge not by color of skin but by content of character" quote went from north star to terribly problematic. The new progressive skeleton key was King's quote about his grave disappointment with the white moderate. That quote was never interpreted in its 1960s context, and created an environment where people had to continuously one-up each other in their social justice radicalism, to avoid being part of King's supposed "white moderate".
Taboos against "racism" went from a social contract (anyone could, in principle, be racist to anyone else, and the standards are identical, at least in theory) to a rhetorical weapon (black people are definitionally incapable of being racist to white people because "racism = power + prejudice").
This cultural shift created backlash which destroyed race relations. Scroll through X on any Thursday and you can see the old "judge not by color of skin but by content of character" social contract is looking pretty dead. A great tragedy.
https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2019/06/the-nytimes-is-woke.html
https://news.gallup.com/poll/1687/race-relations.aspx